6.6: Caring Reduces to Paternalism or Persuasion
kill-condition
ClaimIf operationalizing caring produces only paternalism or persuasion as implementable options, the caring orientation cannot be instantiated as specified.
If operationalizing caring produces only two implementable options -- paternalism (machine overrides user choice "for their own good") or persuasion (machine technically respects autonomy but optimizes compliance through framing) -- then the caring orientation cannot be instantiated as specified.
Distinct from 6.4 (irresolvable paternalism) because it identifies a second failure mode: a system that looks non-paternalistic but achieves the same control through sophisticated framing.